1: Mirror Sequence: At the heart of this artwork, a series of mirrors captures and magnifies the actors' intensified expressions, serving as a metaphor for the complex reality of African American identity. This imagery reflects the multifaceted personas that Black performers often adopted, navigating between their roles on stage and in society. Echoing W.E.B. Du Bois' concept of double consciousness, Makeup underscores the perpetual awareness of the white gaze upon the individual consciousness of African Americans. Du Bois' notion highlights the continuous negotiation of self-awareness and external perception, illustrating a fundamental aspect of the African American experience.

2: Telegrams and Well Wishes: Positioned around the mirrors, the flutter of envelopes symbolizes the personal histories of many African American artists residing in Harlem whose families remained in the South. This imagery alludes to the Great Migration, a period of the early 20th century when many African Americans relocated to northern cities in search of employment opportunities and improved quality of life, escaping the oppressive conditions of sharecropping and racial violence.

3: Actors' Exaggerated Expressions: Mirrored in each reflection, the actors' expressions evoke theatrical motifs and the notion of concealing one's authentic identity. Minstrel shows, initially staged by white actors in blackface, stood out as an early form of American theater. These acts featured exaggerated caricatures of African Americans, employing overstated dialects, actions, and appearances to ridicule and demean for amusement. By the mid-19th century, African American performers also started to engage, frequently due to pressure or as one of the few avenues available for earning a living, perpetuating the complex legacy of minstrel shows.

4: Foreground Card Game: This segment of the painting captures two performers engrossed in an animated card game, highlighting moments of daily life and fellowship. It subtly nods to Paul Cézanne’s renowned work, The Card Players, showcasing Lawrence’s deep appreciation for both art history and his recognition of card games as a significant cultural practice within African American communities. Playing cards have traditionally served as a means of communal bonding, offering a platform for friendly competition, and acting as a social hub for community interaction.

As America’s newly ascendant Gilded Age elite sought both validation and distinction, John Singer Sargent (1856–1925) offered something entirely new. Born to American parents in Florence and trained in Paris, Sargent bridged European tradition and American identity, bringing academic precision to a clientele eager to define its place on the world stage. His portraits of influential figures, from Theodore Roosevelt to Isabella Stewart Gardner, gave American portraiture a distinctly fresh, painterly expression that encapsulated a nation coming into its own.

La Carmencita by John Singer Sargent, painted 1890. M.S. Rau

Depicting the celebrated Spanish dancer La Carmencita, this work immortalizes one of the first internationally recognized stars of the stage. She captivated audiences on both sides of the Atlantic, embodying the energy of modern entertainment. As noted by film historians, she may have even been among the first women ever captured in a commercially produced motion picture, signaling the dawn of a new visual culture. Sargent met La Carmencita at a gathering at fellow artist William Merritt Chase’s studio, where he was dazzled by her talent. He persuaded the dancer to sit for a portrait with him, and was soon writing to his famed patron Isabella Steward Gardner of his progress: “You must come to the studio on Tuesday and see the figure I’m doing of the bewilderingly superb creature.”

La Carmencita dancing, circa 1890. Source

Mrs. Fiske Warren (Gretchen Osgood) and Her Daughter Rachel by John Singer Sargent. MFA, Boston. Source

Norman Rockwell, circa 1921. Source

A Scout is Friendly by Norman Rockwell, painted 1943. M.S. Rau

Self-portrait by John Singer Sargent, circa 1892. National Academy of Design. Source

La Carmencita by John Singer Sargent, circa 1890. Musée d’Orsay. Source

The 20th century signaled a great shift in American culture, and perhaps no artist more profoundly shaped the era’s identity than Norman Rockwell (1894–1978). Over more than six decades, he created over 4,000 original works, including 321 covers for The Saturday Evening Post. These heartwarming images entered millions of households and established a shared visual language of American life that endured for generations. Rockwell painted portraits of five U.S. presidents and was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 1977, cementing his status as one of America’s defining artists.

Rockwell’s work for the Boy Scouts of America became one of his most meaningful commissions. In masterworks such as A Scout is Friendly, he portrayed scouting as a reflection of national ideals—friendship, responsibility and service. His illustrations for calendars and Boys’ Life became familiar fixtures in American homes. Remarkably, he waived royalties for these commissions, assigning reproduction rights to the organization as a gesture of conviction in its values.

Longnook Valley by Edward Hopper, painted 1934. M.S. Rau

As American expansionism and industrialization reshaped the physical landscape, Edward Hopper (1882–1967) turned his eye inward, capturing the solitude and quiet tension of modern life. In a nation whose identity was so deeply tied to place—its diners, gas stations, city apartments and coastal bluffs—Hopper found in those settings a mirror for the internal human condition. His paintings act as windows into existence itself, where light and shadow reveal the profound emotional depths of 20th-century America.

Painted in 1934 on Hopper’s beloved Cape Cod, Longnook Valley is a radiant watercolor capturing the iconic brilliance of a New England autumn. A winding road anchors the composition, vanishing into a dramatic band of trees and drawing the viewer inward with the quiet mystery that is quintessentially Hopper—transforming a specific American place into something universally felt.

Edward Hopper in New York, 1937. Source

Nighthawks by Edward Hopper, circa 1962. The Art Institute of Chicago. Source

Painted Visions

Painted Visions